“The educational foundations of our society are presently being eroded by a rising tide of mediocrity that threatens our very future as a nation and as a people,” wrote the authors of the 1983 report “A Nation at Risk.”

Since the report’s publication revealed the extent of the United States’ far from exceptional public education, there has been an emphasis on the need to increase rigor in our curriculum and provide for STEM courses to compete with other knowledge economies. With it came an influx of standardized curriculum, like the Common Core and testing in public schools; it also seems more than coincidental that the popularity of AP tests has grown significantly almost every year since the 1980s. While these courses were originally created to challenge high-performing students further, it seems rare to find a student at PHS not taking these Advanced Placement “university-level courses.” On the surface level, we see tremendous progress in the effort and expectation for students at PHS and around the country. But we don’t seem to be better as a nation.

The Program for International Student Assessment (PISA) is universally recognized as a benchmark to assess and compare national education systems in different countries, testing 15-year-olds on essential math, reading, and science knowledge and skills. Despite funding for education increasing per pupil every year, the United States’ PISA scores have stagnated or even decreased the past decade. This doesn’t seem to match the fact that alongside millions of students nationwide, PHS students pushed themselves to take a record amount of 1660 AP exams in total this year.

Recently, there has been an avalanche of disappointing decisions by College Board, which is continuing to decrease benchmarks in multiple avenues of standardized testing such as the AP, PSAT, and SAT exams. Under the convoluted mess of positive statistics seems to lie an opposite reality, a downward trend in expectation that seems oddly similar to the fears that led to the publication of “A Nation at Risk.” For example, to be considered “extremely well qualified” in the AP Physics C: Electricity and Magnetism Exam, students need to score just above 50 percent of the total points available. Other more subtle changes show up in the difficulty of texts in the AP Language Arts and Composition exam or the complexity of questions given in history exams (not to mention the changes to the rubric). Are we stooping to a lower standard in education? With the powerful influence that College Board wields today in curriculum, it seems undeniable. Considering these developments, the very ideals that define American exceptionalism seem at odds with the direction of our schools.

In some ways, the changes are a result of public pressure. The push for self-contentment, relaxation, and work-life boundaries leads us to the conclusion that mediocrity is a far better fate than misery. However, although the US is facing a mental health crisis, especially among young adults, decreasing the expectations and benchmarks of what we can achieve is only further detrimental to education and the self-confidence of the generation most affected by the COVID-19 pandemic.

Simply put, students are confused. This confusion is felt frequently on social media, where students are swayed to believe they can prioritize their mental health, half-committing to learning, while working arduously to be somewhat comparable to other students in the “How I got into *insert university*” videos plaguing their screens. The rise of satisficing in education reflects America’s shifting priorities, exacerbated by the “dumbing down” of expectations that were seemingly achievable just a few years ago. One can’t help to feel as if the United States’ education system is shying away from difficult experimentation and implementation to improve education, and instead deciding to acquiesce in a whirlwind of damaged attention spans and complaints.

It is human nature to want things to stay easy. But for developing teens, when we ignore the growth that can come from pressure, the successive appeasement in the name of overbearing stress removes conviction when surmounting future obstacles. The comfort we feel in mediocrity right now is only temporary.

By definition, only a few are exceptional. But for each individual and as a society, the intense drive to improve upon the previous generation is necessary in order to exceed the stagnation that we currently face. Everyone wants to be the best version of themselves, so let’s put that idea into practice.